Wednesday, May 27, 2020


In Sickness and in Wealth

As a registered nurse I see the effects of how wealth effects health.  In the film In Sickness and in Wealth, Larry Alderman Didn't show us how to cure illness but instead opened our eyes to how income, race, and social status impacts our quality of health as seen in Louisville Kentucky.  This is a problem every and not just in Kentucky.  So the question is does inequity make us sick? I agree that it does.  It is like nurture vs. nature, or genes vs. social involvement.  Each has a different outcome depending on the variables.  For Example two identical twins can live together in the same environment from childhood to young adult and have the same good health.  When they start to live different lifestyles the one educated with a higher income with no worries and the other with a lower income and many worries who share the same genes now start to have different health changes. One being in good health, the other in poor health.  What is actually being seen here is that higher incomes structures and resources have the best health.  According to the film the United States has the greatest income inequity. So who does this affect?  This affects the poorest sections as well as the middle class.  The reasoning to this is because the poor and the middle class have more stressors like the lower paying jobs and not being able to pay the bills.  

With increased stress comes underlying conditions which can lead to bad health. 
 So why does this happen?  When your stress increases your cortisol levels increase which over a long period of time can have negative effects on your health.  Elevated cortisol can impair your immune system.  This can lead to issues with your memory and brain functions.  It can also cause wear and tear on your body as well as damage you systems which can lead to heart disease and diabetes.  With this higher rate of disease your body will have and accelerated rate in aging which leads to early mortality.

 Big stressors presently, is the COVID-19 pandemic and  the fear of catching the virus.  Many people are not able to work because they are being forced to stay home and unemployment is up throughout the country.  This is tough because many people who were laid off do not have a back up plan because they didn't have a savings account and previously lived check to check.  Another fear is that  now that some the middle class and poor now have to remain in their jobs, the "front liners" and don't have the option to work from home.  In their minds this increases the risk of catching the virus.  This increase in worry and stress can cause long term issues in their health.  In RI alone unemployment is over 16%.  The longer this continues the increase in stress in the population and possible long term PTSD effects from this are irreversible.  Though some people may not show signs of bad health now in the future their my be repercussions from this. 



Figure 1





Adelman, L. (Director). (2008). In Sickness and in Wealth [Video file]. California Newsreel. Retrieved May 25, 2020, from Kanopy.

3 comments:

  1. Hi Julie,
    As an RN I am concerned about my and coworker's health. Every day we experience the stress of wondering "could that client be infected?" or "am I going to get my family sick when I get home?". The death toll among healthcare workers breaks my heart as many of these deaths could have been prevented. I also think about patients whom are reluctant to seek medical health due to fear of getting infected. I have many clients who have hypertension and uncontrolled diabetes and I'm afraid of the consequences they'll suffer by not seeking help!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi, Julie-- I really appreciate your point of view as a nurse. I know that you very vividly many of the health consequences of COVID-19. You listed in your post a number of stress related effects from COVID-19. The film specifically indicated that stress is a caused by differences in income. Do you think that the stresses you listed are only felt by people of all income levels? I found a report (link at the end of comments) that talks about the savings among families in the US. I found it interesting that people of all classes say they don't have enough savings--yet it does also show the gaps are different among different income groups, race and and age.

    Agreeably unemployment causes stress, but as you said, so does going to work at this time. What could we do to address both of those causes of stress at the same time? Is there a way to help people be employed safely?

    Thanks again for your insight!
    Michelle

    https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/about/news-room/press-releases-and-statements/2015/11/18/pew-finds-american-families-ill-equipped-for-financial-emergencies

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for these helpful insights, Julie. Your post makes me wonder: What kind of society would it take to withstand a health crisis like the current one? What kinds of social supports do people need, and what would it take to get them? Educational philosopher George Counts once famously asked "Dare the school build a new social order?" and it makes me wonder how we as folks working with young people can participate in the positive transformation of our society...

    ReplyDelete

"Stay Woke" and "Mighty Times"

                                                   It Takes Children To Be Heard After watching two powerful videos "Stay Woke" an...